OK this is the first part of overly long commentary about the new Sondheim CD set “The Story So Far” cuz I’m bored and I’m listening to it and I am somewhat compulsive about expressing my opinion. Lucky you.
First, after importing all the songs from the four (!) CDs into iTunes, I had to put them in chronological order because that’s how my brain knows the material and I get confused easily in my peri-menopausal old age. So the order in my review isn’t quite the same as on the CDs but it’s pretty close. Mostly I just interspersed CD 4 into the other stuff where it belonged historically.
Just to annoy you I’m gonna do a show by show kinda commentary only some songs I might not comment on because I don’t want to bore you all too much so just ignore the stuff you don’t know/care about. OK, here goes:
I Must Be Dreaming (1948 All That Glitters) OK, not much to say about this except it’s from his college days and I gotta say the boy was quite accomplished even back then.
The Two of You (1952 Kukla, Fran and Ollie TV show) They rejected it, too bad, cuz I used to watch this show as a young kiddie and mighta become a Sondheim fanatic at age 3 instead of age 13 or so. Except I wasn’t born yet when this song was written. Oh well.
Saturday Night (1954) Not really all that impressed, but it’s “lost” stuff, although one of my old CDs had at least one song from this show, but I forget which one and I’m too lazy to dig out the disks to find out. Too bad I wasn’t compulsive when I imported those into iTunes.
They Ask Me Why I Believe in You (1956) From a TV script that never got produced. Bernadette Peters recorded this and it’s on her Sondheim, etc, etc CD but I like Steve’s version better just cuz he’s so cute when he sings his own stuff.
West Side Story (1957) Wow flashback, this was my first Sondheim show, only I didn’t know it at the time. But I loved this show. A lot. This show and Gypsy were my first favorite musicals. And they were both touched by Sondheim. Coincidence? I think not!
Gypsy (1959) The other early fave. As a small kiddie I was dragged to rehearsals of musicals (my divorced mom was a violinist and musicals were easy to play for quick money) and I vividly remember sitting in the empty theater of this show during show rehearsals and watching everyone up there on stage and thinking “Wow, I wish I could do that!” I fell in love with the show and got bitten by the theatre bug all at the same time. And I learned every song and every line by heart and recited them in the car on the way home every night. Much to my mother’s dismay (her personal “favorite” was “You Gotta Have a Gimmick” that I did, complete with hip gestures, which embarrassed her to no end which of course just encouraged me more.) The recording on the CD is from the original Broadway cast featuring The Merm herself (I have the vinyl of this album somewhere too ….)
Invitation to a March (1960) Never heard this before that I know of, it’s kind of pretty, although out of context so it doesn’t make much sense since it’s just cue music.
A Funny Thing Happened on the Way to the Forum (1962) My least favorite Sondheim show, although the movie is pretty funny, I had to watch it again in college in my Comic Spirit class which was a class where we “studied” humor (we really just watched funny movies and cartoons, and did a bit of reading from things like “The Decameron” but hey it counted for GE credit and the teacher told dumb jokes only he thought were funny.)
Truly Content (1962 Passionella) Another one with The Master himself singing. Was later part of the show The Apple Tree which in a later revival starred one of my favorite musical theatre performers Kristin Chenoweth. So I guess it’s OK.
Don’t Laugh (1963 Hot Spot) Another one I’ve never heard, from a show I never heard of. I kind of like this song. And it’s sung by Sondheim on the CD. Did I mention he sounds cute when he sings?
Anyone Can Whistle (1964) It’s nice to have yet another recording of some of the songs from this show. I already have the concert version thingie that came out uhm … 10 years or so ago with Bernadette Peters, Angela Lansbury, Madeline Kahn, Scott Bakula and a bunch other great peeps, but I don’t have the original cast album. Maybe I should get it. The show is a bit wacky and hard to follow but it has some great songs, including the title song that I used to use as an audition song.
Do I Hear a Waltz? (1965) Oh man, this stuff is great. A show I’d forgotten about. And a couple of the songs on the CD are previously unreleased songs from the demo recording!
The Mad Show (1966) I swear I remember hearing Linda Lavin singing this song on TV long, long ago. What the hell ever happened to her? She did that TV show Alice and her career died or something. This may be the only recording I ever get of her singing.
Evening Primrose (1966) Who knew Tony Perkins could sing? I like the versions from Mandy Patinkin’s Dress Casual album better, but who knew Tony Perkins could sing? Worth it just for that!
No, Mary Ann (1969 The Thing Of It Is) I don’t like this one much. Steve doesn’t sound cute on this one. And it’s kind of generic in a Sondheimy way.
Another Hundred People (1970 Company) I really like this song, I’m not sure why. It also makes a great audition song if you can pull it off. This recording is from the original cast I think, with Pamela Myers, who, if I’m not mistaken, I saw in the touring production of Sunday in the Park with George (with the original sets and costumes from the Broadway production, so close, yet so very far ….)
The Ladies Who Lunch (1970 Company) Elaine Stritch at her classic best. This is a gotta have it.
Being Alive (1970 Company) This is from one of my top three Sondheim musicals ever. And every time I see it I “get it” more and more (probably because I mature a bit between viewings.) In my opinion probably the deepest show Sondheim’s ever written in regards to his understanding of people. The song “Being Alive” is probably the best song he’s ever written. I’ve heard several performers sing it, both within and out of the context of the show. It’s nice to hear another recording of it. My personal favorite rendition though is Raul Esparza from the recent revival but maybe I should buy the original cast recording too.
Happily Ever After (1970 Company) I like this song, too bad it was cut from the show. I also have another recording of this from the Collector’s Sondheim CD (performed by Craig Lucas) but this one is sung by Sondheim himself.
Follies (1971) This show isn’t one of my favorites but it has some great songs. Most notably the fabulous Elaine Stritch singing Broadway Baby (which I like a whole lot better than the Bernadette Peters’ cutesy version.) Add in other performances from the Follies in Concert recording by Carol Burnett (I’m Still Here) and Barbara Cook (Losing My Mind) and others and it’s a hit. My only complaint is there isn’t anything from the original cast. But maybe it was never recorded? The concert version is a great recording though.
OK I’m gonna end here because I’m tired of typing. Part two later, starting with A Little Night Music. Gads and I’m only halfway through CD 2 ….